Watch on Relay
Lists

Weird movies: how a surreal western started the "midnight movie"

A reflection that walks out of a mirror, a brain hiding in a dog, a deli that decides your future: 8 strange films.

By Relay, Watch Guide · Monday, November 16, 2026 · 6 min read

A weird movie is one that stops following the rules of an ordinary story. In place of plain realism it puts irrational, absurd or dreamlike images on screen, and it lets them stand without explanation. The idea has a birthplace. In 1920s Paris, the surrealists, a group of artists who wanted to paint and film the logic of dreams, carried their methods into cinema. The most famous result, Un Chien Andalou (1929), grew out of the filmmaker Luis Buñuel and the painter Salvador Dalí trading their dreams, and the two agreed to include nothing that could be rationally explained.

Strange films then found their audience at night. In December 1970, El Topo, a surreal western by the director Alejandro Jodorowsky, opened at the Elgin Theater in New York and played at midnight seven nights a week until the end of June 1971. It is credited with starting the midnight movie, a late screening of a film too odd for prime time. David Lynch's Eraserhead (1977) became a midnight hit at the Waverly Theater from 1978, and that circuit built the modern idea of the cult film. In 1988 the Toronto International Film Festival made it official with a nightly section called Midnight Madness.

Relay has the 8 films below, from 1913 to 2022. Some are strange by design, some by budget, and one is about an artist whose nightmarish paintings ended up in a Hollywood blockbuster.

What makes a weird movie

  • A broken rule of reality. A reflection gets up and leaves, a path loops back on itself, a brain floats outside its body.
  • No apology. The film rarely stops to explain the strangeness. The characters accept it, and the audience has to as well.
  • Dream logic. Scenes connect the way they do in sleep, by feeling and image more than by cause and effect.
  • Ordinary places made uncanny. A deli, a pond, a housing block, a farmhouse: the setting is familiar, and that is what makes it unsettling.

8 weird movies to watch

The Student of Prague (1913)

Balduin, a poor student, sells his reflection to a mysterious stranger for a fortune. The reflection then steps out of the mirror and starts living his life, and ruining it. The story is a variation on the Faust legend, and the German actor Paul Wegener plays both the student and his double in his film debut.

The cinematographer Guido Seeber used double exposure to put Wegener and his double in the same frame. Film historians, among them Heide Schlüpmann in an essay titled "The first German art film", call this the first German art film, the work that helped move cinema from the fairground toward a respected art. Critics have traced its shadowy lighting forward to The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920), and the psychoanalyst Otto Rank wrote about it in his 1914 essay on the double.

Drama

The Student of Prague

Hanns Heinz Ewers · 1913 · 41 min

Watch on Relay

The Brain from Planet Arous (1957)

Gor, a giant floating brain from the planet Arous, takes over the body of a nuclear scientist, Steve March, to conquer Earth. A second, good brain named Vol has followed him, and it hides inside the family dog, George, waiting for the moment Gor leaves Steve's body and becomes vulnerable. To show the alien inside him, the star John Agar wore contact lenses lined with metal foil, which turned his eyes blank and silver.

The director Nathan Juran was unhappy with the film and signed it with a pseudonym, Nathan Hertz. It was largely forgotten and later became a favourite of bad movie revivals. It also left a mark on one famous reader. Stephen King, the horror novelist, told the magazine Cinefantastique that this film was "in some way I've never been able to figure out, the basis for my novel Carrie."

Horror

The Brain from Planet Arous

Nathan Juran · 1957 · 71 min

Watch on Relay

All the Kind Strangers (1974)

A photojournalist, played by Stacy Keach, gives a boy a lift home through the Tennessee backwoods. At the farmhouse he finds seven orphans living alone, and a woman, played by Samantha Eggar, whom they are already holding. The children want the two strangers to become their parents. Earlier visitors who tried to leave have vanished, and the eldest boy has been hiding their cars in a swimming hole.

It first aired on ABC as a Movie of the Week on 12 November 1974, directed by Burt Kennedy and shot in Lebanon, Tennessee. Two later stars, the young John Savage and Robby Benson, play two of the orphans. One critic called it a small-screen Deliverance: horror made out of a quiet farm and a polite request.

Horror

All the Kind Strangers

Burt Kennedy · 1974 · 74 min

Watch on Relay

Dark Star: H. R. Giger's World (2014)

H. R. Giger, the Swiss surrealist painter and sculptor, designed the creature in Ridley Scott's Alien (1979) and was part of the team that won the Academy Award for Best Visual Effects for it. His art, in other words, became one of the most famous monsters in cinema. This documentary by the Swiss director Belinda Sallin debuted at the Zurich Film Festival in September 2014.

Sallin filmed Giger in the last years of his life, and he died on 12 May 2014, aged 74, after a fall. The camera walks through his house in Zurich, where he still kept the first skull his father gave him when he was six, along with souvenirs from the Alien set. The film also covers his album art for musicians such as Debbie Harry and the Dead Kennedys.

Documentary

Dark Star: H. R. Giger's World

Belinda Sallin · 2014 · 95 min

Watch on Relay

Macadam Stories (2015)

An American astronaut, played by Michael Pitt, falls out of the sky and lands on the roof of a run-down French housing block. An Algerian neighbour, Madame Hamida, takes him in and looks after him until NASA comes to collect him. Downstairs, Isabelle Huppert, one of France's best known actors, plays a faded film star who befriends a lonely teenager, played by the director's son Jules.

The writer and director Samuel Benchetrit adapted it from the first volume of his own autobiographical books about growing up on such an estate. He said he was "too influenced by the corridors and staircases of my childhood," and he shot in an abandoned building because he could not afford a studio. It premiered at the Cannes Film Festival on 17 May 2015, and earned him a nomination for the César, France's national film award, for Best Adaptation.

Comedy

Macadam Stories

Samuel Benchetrit · 2015 · 100 min

Watch on Relay

Ham On Rye (2019)

Teenagers gather at a local deli, Monty's, for a rite of passage that decides which of them will leave their suburban town and which will stay for good. Nobody explains the ritual. The second half of the film follows the adults who never left, in a gloomier world after dark.

It is the first feature by Tyler Taormina, who grew up in Smithtown on Long Island, and it uses an ensemble of more than 100 performers, among them non-actors and musicians. It premiered at the Santa Barbara International Film Festival in 2019. Peter Bradshaw of the Guardian gave it 4 stars out of 5 and called it "very individual work, as creepy as a ghost story." Taormina's later Christmas Eve in Miller's Point, starring Michael Cera, premiered at Cannes in 2024.

Drama

Ham On Rye

Tyler Taormina · 2019 · 87 min

Watch on Relay

Asylum: Twisted Horror and Fantasy Tales (2020)

Brandon, a clown and stand-up comedian played by Raymond Lee, takes the stage for his final show, and each story he tells becomes a short film. Film Threat counted nine of them. They come from different directors and countries, and they swing between horror, fantasy and plain oddity.

One segment, The Cleansing Hour by Damien LeVeck, follows a staged exorcism streamed live online; LeVeck expanded it into a feature in 2019. The Film Threat reviewer called the whole thing "a very mixed bag," and that is part of the appeal: an anthology like this is a tour of strange ideas, some of which work.

Comedy

Asylum: Twisted Horror and Fantasy Tales

Nicolás Onetti · 2020 · 117 min

Watch on Relay

Brightwood (2022)

Dan and Jen, a married couple on the edge of divorce, go for a morning run around a pond. Every path leads back to the same "no swimming" sign, and hooded figures chase them around the water. The figures turn out to be themselves. Only two actors appear on screen, Max Woertendyke and Dana Berger.

It is the first feature by Dane Elcar, son of the actor Dana Elcar, best known as the boss in the TV series MacGyver. Elcar wrote and shot it, expanding his 2018 short The Pond. Critics have read the time loop as a picture of a dying marriage, and one compared it to the best classic Twilight Zone episodes.

Sci-Fi

Brightwood

Dane Elcar · 2022 · 85 min

Watch on Relay

Where to go next